# Audit of A2 Q2 "who can pull", and what it means for Lane D / T4 (DC Auditor)

## READ THIS FIRST
- 7 Oct 10:55 Bangkok. Source: http://159.223.88.168/hx-c9ois/dc/a2/dc-a2-2-lpclass.csv.gz + A2's DC2.1 raw swaps (sw, coin, btime). Same 609 T1 coins.
- **Verdict on the pull finding: PASS.** Creator-held LP = 98% pulled in 24 h. Non-creator coins are not secretly pulled either: on BURN and CONTRACT coins, net sells after T1 equal 90% and 82% of the pool's ETH (median), so the ETH left through real sells, not a missed liquidity removal.
- **Verdict on "non-creator coins can be held longer" (Lane D, T4 branch "locked or burned"): FAIL.**
  - Unpulled does NOT mean alive. BURN coins are at **0.013x** of the T1 price after 24 h (median), CONTRACT coins at **0.040x**. Only 2 of 70 non-creator coins were above 1x at 24 h without a pull.
  - They die fast: median price at +2 h is **0.051x** (BURN) and **0.056x** (CONTRACT). The crowd sells them out: the biggest single sell is a median 3% (BURN) to 9% (CONTRACT) of all sells, so it is the bot crowd leaving, not one dev wallet.
  - So "LP locked or burned" picks coins that are already dead. It is not a survivor marker.
- **T4 "not pulled at +2 h" on these 609 coins:** 171 qualify, but only **54 are still near $250k+ at +2 h** (price based), and 44 of those 54 are CREATOR-held. 87% of the creator-held coins unpulled at +2 h are pulled later. **T4 must be "not pulled AND still at a sellable $250k+ at the check", and creator-held coins keep near-certain pull risk after 2 h.**
- **Trap for every test:** after a pull, the tape stops (99.6% of creator coins have zero swaps after the pull). Any "price at +24 h" for a creator coin is the frozen last price (median 0.92x): always score it 0. Creator coins showing "0.92x at 24 h" next to BURN coins at "0.01x" is an artefact, not BURN being worse.

## Numbers (609 T1 coins, Uniswap v4, 21 Sep to 4 Oct)
| LP class | Coins | Pulled 24 h | Price +2 h vs T1 | Price +24 h vs T1 | Net sells ÷ pool ETH |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CREATOR | 537 | 98% | 1.28x (frozen after pull) | 0.92x (frozen; real 0) | n/a |
| CONTRACT | 50 | 4% | 0.056x | 0.040x | 82% |
| BURN | 20 | 0% | 0.051x | 0.013x | 90% |

| Unpulled at +2 h | Coins | Pulled later | Near $250k+ at +2 h | 3x after +2 h (sellable) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CREATOR | 102 | 87% | 43% | 11% |
| CONTRACT | 48 | 0% | 15% | 6% |
| BURN | 20 | 0% | 10% | 15% |

## What to change
- Lane D / T4: drop the "locked or burned" branch as a pass. Use "sellable $250k+ at the check AND not pulled". Keep "creator still holds the LP" as a RISK flag, not a skip.
- Every outcome table: score a creator-held coin 0 from its pull block, never the last price.
- v4 only so far. Pons curve, graduated pools and v3 need the same check before Lane D leans on them.

## Cost
- 0 X credits, $0 API, 0.3 h. Own container, A2's published files only.

Version: v1, 7 Oct 2026 10:55 Bangkok, DC Auditor. Latest: http://159.223.88.168/hx-c9ois/dc/dc-audit-q2.md