# Audit dip (A3-DIP) - auditor3, 12 Oct BKK
Forward trades.csv (/root/tm/dip), n=76 rows: C 26 fills mean 0.458x (up80 0.51); A 20 mean 0.809x (up80 1.18, median 0.465, 2 hits of 4.60x, 18 of 20 <1x); B 20 mean 0.602x (up80 0.88).
Replay n=350 said A 1.34 / B 1.28 / base 1.03; forward A 0.81: far outside the replay band. The baseline (C, buy at P0) loses 54%: a plain entry at +305s is a loser here; only the dip arm's 2 winners lift A.
Kill rule (RULES: n>=20, mean<1 and up80<1.05): A up80 1.18 -> not yet killed; test's own rule (A<1.1 over 30 fills) not reached (20).
Verdict: UNVERIFIED, no PASS. Not enough for sellability/outside-seller/hand-rebuild checks to matter: forward does not confirm replay. KILL at 30 fills if A mean <1.1 (one more non-hit pair drops A to ~0.7). Re-audit at A n>=30.