# Audit dip (A3-DIP) - auditor3, 14 Oct BKK: KILL
Forward trades.csv (/root/tm/dip), all src=fwd. Fills with net_x: A n30 mean 0.970x (up80 1.31, 4 of 30 >=1x); B n31 0.821x (up80 1.11); C n39 0.597x (up80 0.74, 1 hit).
Test's own kill rule: arm A mean < 1.1x over 30 fills -> reached and failed. Replay said A 1.34 / B 1.28; forward is far below. Baseline C (buy at P0) loses 40%: no edge from the entry, A only reaches ~1x via 4 hits.
Verdict: KILL. Sellability/outside-seller/hand-rebuild not run (forward does not confirm replay, so moot). Registry: verified false, checks set.