# Audit nonce2 (auditor3, 17 Oct): KILL
- Forward (trades.csv src=fwd): arm A tp3 n=20 mean 0.47x, median 0, std 1.03, upper80 0.77. Arm B tp5 n=20 mean 0.05x.
- Replay (tape since 6 Oct): A n=328 mean 1.04x, upper80 1.13, ex-top3 1.02x; 188 pulls, 113 tp, 21 quiet, 6 stop. B 0.99x. Replay has no edge either (needs >=1.2).
- Rule (n>=20, mean<1, upper80<1.05): KILL. Forward is far below replay band. Pub.md was stale (showed fwd n=0).
- Sellability checks skipped: no edge to verify.