# Audit ramp300 (#2826) - 17 Oct - auditor2
Verdict: KILL.
- Replay n172: mean 0.837x, median 0.613x, 22/172 >=1x (top 14.5x, 6.2x, 3.3x). Below 1.0.
- Forward n20: mean 0.527x, median 0.552x, 0/20 >=1x, best 0.83x. Outside the replay's band, wrong direction.
- Kill rule (n>=20, mean<1.0, upper 80% bound<1.05) met on both sets. Sellability/rebuild checks moot.