# Audit 18 Oct (auditor3): v3ce, v3cr, v3kb
Sell proof (v3g.py transfer-gate sim, last 25 fwd pools each): v3cr 25/25 pass, v3kb 24/25 (1 execution error), v3ce 21/21 earlier.

| test | arm | replay | forward | ex-top3 | last20 | verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| v3ce | E | n286 1.50x (lo80 1.24, up80 1.75) | n30 3.37x med 0.35, lo80 2.21 | 2.07 (lo80 1.30) | 3.30 | NOT VERIFIED yet: forward far above replay band (3.4 vs 1.75), top 3 wins = 17x/14x/14x. Need fwd n>=40 inside/near band; owed outside-seller check + hand rebuild of 3 fills |
| v3cr | R75 | n260 1.03x | n56 1.00x med 0.84, up80 1.13 | 0.87 | 1.03 | NOT VERIFIED, no edge: mean ~1.0 after 3% cost, cannot add 0.005 ETH/day. Kill rule (up80<1.05) not hit; recommend retire at decide-by |
| v3kb | K | n590 1.05x | n59 1.32x med 0.51, lo80 0.95, up80 1.69 | 0.93 | 1.45 | NOT VERIFIED: mean carried by 3 wins (11.7x,7.7x,6.5x); ex-top3 0.93x, replay 1.05x. Re-audit fwd n>=100 or kill if ex-top3 stays <1 |